Why Custom Moulds Beat Domes in Background Noise* (Most of the time)

*Most of the time.

If your main goal is hearing better in background noise, a custom-made earmould or custom receiver will almost always outperform a standard silicone dome. The reason is simple physics: a dome lets sound leak in and out of your ear canal, and that leak quietly undoes much of what your hearing aid’s noise features are trying to do.

Domes and custom moulds are both what hearing professionals call acoustic couplings: the part that couples, or connects, your hearing aid’s sound to your ear canal. It’s easy to think of the coupling as a minor accessory, but it has a big effect on how well your hearing aid performs.

In a Swedish study (Magnusson et al., 2013) comparing the two on the same hearing aids, directional microphones improved speech understanding in noise by 4.4 dB with a sealed acrylic mould, but only 1.6 dB with an open dome (summarised in Winkler et al., 2016). Every decibel matters in noise: small changes in signal-to-noise ratio make a big difference to how many words you catch.

That matters most when you have invested in premium hearing aids. Their biggest advantage over cheaper models is how well they handle noise, and a leaky fit can leave much of that advantage on the table. This article explains why, so you can make an informed choice.

How sound escapes: the acoustics in plain English

When you wear a hearing aid, two kinds of sound reach your eardrum:

  1. Processed sound, which has passed through the hearing aid’s microphones and computer chip. This is where all the clever noise reduction happens.
  2. Direct sound, which travels straight into your ear canal through any gap or vent, completely untouched by the hearing aid.

An open dome is designed to let lots of direct sound in. That keeps your ears feeling natural, but it creates three problems in noise.

The noise comes in the side door. With an open fitting, the direct sound usually dominates everything up to about 1,500 Hz. Below that point, the hearing aid’s processing has essentially no influence on what you hear (Winkler et al., 2016). Much of the rumble of a busy cafe or club sits in exactly that range, and it walks straight past your hearing aid.

Amplified sound leaks back out. The same gap that lets noise in lets amplified sound escape, especially the lower frequencies. Your hearing aid has to work harder to deliver what you need, and some of it never reaches your eardrum.

Feedback limits how much help you can get. Sound leaking out can be picked up again by the microphones and cause whistling. Researchers found the maximum stable gain before feedback was 25 dB lower with open domes and 15 dB lower with closed domes than with individually made earmoulds (Winkler et al., 2016). Modern feedback cancellation recovers some of this, but it can introduce artefacts, particularly with music.

A well-fitted custom mould controls all three. It gives your clinician a defined, predictable vent instead of an uncontrolled leak, so the amount of direct sound can be set deliberately for your hearing loss.

Why noise features need a sealed fit

The headline features of modern hearing aids, directional microphones and noise reduction, can only clean up the sound they process. Anything that leaks in around the earpiece skips that processing altogether.

The effect is easy to see when the same directional microphone is tested with different fittings. Widex researchers reported these results for one adaptive directional system (Kuk et al., Hearing Review, 2005):

How the hearing aid was fittedImprovement in signal-to-noise ratio from the directional microphone
Open fitting, no occlusion1.8 dB
Earmould with a vent of 2.0 to 2.5 mm or less4 to 6 dB
Unvented fitting (more severe hearing loss)6 to 8 dB

Same microphone, same processing, very different results. The only thing that changed was how well the ear canal was sealed.

The same researchers concluded that people with a moderate or worse hearing loss in the low and mid frequencies, or with a mild high-frequency loss but a severe difficulty hearing in noise, may not be good candidates for an open fitting (Kuk et al., 2005). In those cases, a properly vented earmould is needed to get the full benefit of the hearing aids.

This is also why we measure your speech-in-noise ability at your hearing assessment. If your results show you struggle a lot in noise, that is a strong signal that a custom fit will make a real difference.

Domes versus custom moulds: why the material and shape matter

Domes are small, mass-produced silicone tips that come in a handful of sizes and styles: open (with holes), vented, closed, and double or “power” domes. They are thin and flexible so they can squash into many different ear canals. That flexibility is also their weakness. A dome is an approximation of your ear canal, not a copy of it. It can sit slightly off-centre, crease, or shift as your jaw moves when you talk and chew, opening small gaps that let sound leak.

Even a closed dome doesn’t seal like a custom mould. Testing of receiver-in-canal hearing aids found that below 1,000 Hz, open and “occluded” domes leaked about the same amount, and closed domes did not seal the ear canal as well as unvented custom earmoulds (Winkler et al., 2016).

Custom moulds are made from an impression of your own ear, so they follow its exact shape. An earmould lab’s technical director lists the advantages of custom earmoulds over universal domes as seal, retention, acoustics, comfort and appearance (Uslu, AudiologyOnline, 2018). The main materials are:

MaterialWhat it’s likeGood for
AcrylicHard, durable, hypoallergenic, often clear and discreet. The standard material for receiver-in-canal moulds. Easy for your clinician to adjust in clinic.Most adults, especially seniors, whose ears tend to be softer and hold a firm mould better
SiliconeSoft, comfortable, durable, doesn’t shrink. Some types give an excellent seal but are harder to modify in clinic.People who find hard moulds uncomfortable, or need a very tight seal
Soft vinylSoft and comfortable but prone to shrinking; generally replaced within about 12 monthsMainly children

Source: Uslu, AudiologyOnline, 2018

It’s the custom shape, not just the material, that creates the seal. Hard acrylic and soft silicone can both seal well when the ear impression is accurate and the mould is well made. The real difference is between a mould shaped to your ear and a dome that only approximates it.

At AIM Hearing we usually recommend acrylic for most adults. It holds its shape for years, stays stable when you talk and chew, and lets us fine-tune the fit and vent in clinic.

Getting your own voice right: occlusion and venting

The most common complaint with a sealed fit is your own voice. When the ear canal is blocked, the vibrations from your voice that normally escape out of the ear get trapped. Your voice can sound too loud, “boomy” or “hollow”, like talking in a barrel. This is called the occlusion effect (Winkler et al., 2016).

The fix is not to give up on a custom mould. It’s to get the vent right. A vent is a small channel through the mould that lets some air and sound pass, so your own voice can escape. Research summarised in the same review found:

  • Each 1 mm increase in vent diameter reduced the measured occlusion effect by about 4 dB.
  • A vent of about 2 mm is regarded as a good starting point for fixing occlusion.
  • The right vent size depends mainly on your hearing at low frequencies (around 500 Hz). The better your low-frequency hearing, the bigger the vent you can usually have.

There is a balance to strike. A bigger vent makes your voice sound more natural, but lets more noise in and more amplified sound out. A smaller vent gives the noise features more to work with, but can make your voice sound boomy. Getting it right is individual.

That’s why we sometimes adjust the vent after your fitting. Because acrylic moulds can be modified in clinic, we can widen a vent if your voice sounds hollow, and we check the result with Real Ear Measurement, which we do on every fitting. Most people find their own voice settles within the first couple of weeks as the brain adjusts, so we usually give it a little time before changing anything.

RIC with a custom mould, or a fully custom hearing aid?

There are two ways to get a custom fit:

  • Receiver-in-canal (RIC) with a custom mould. The hearing aid sits behind your ear, and only the receiver (speaker) sits in your ear canal, inside a mould made for you.
  • A fully custom hearing aid such as an ITE (in-the-ear), ITC (in-the-canal), CIC (completely-in-canal) or IIC (invisible-in-canal). Everything, including the microphone, is built into a shell made from your ear impression.

Both seal your ear well. The big difference is where the microphone sits, and that changes what the hearing aid hears.

A RIC’s microphones sit behind and above your ear. That’s a convenient spot for two microphones a fixed distance apart, which is what directional processing and features like deep neural network noise reduction need. But it means sound reaches the microphones before your outer ear (the pinna) has shaped it. Your pinna adds subtle cues that help you tell whether a sound is in front of you or behind you.

A custom hearing aid’s microphone sits at the entrance to your ear canal, so it hears sound after your pinna has shaped it, much as your ear naturally would. An acoustic analysis of five hearing aid styles found the invisible-in-canal style captured directional cues most like an unaided ear, and the behind-the-ear style the least (Kara et al., 2024, summarising Durin et al., 2014).

What the research shows

  • Telling front from back. In a study of 11 people with hearing loss, CIC hearing aids produced fewer front-back mix-ups than behind-the-ear hearing aids (Best et al., 2010).
  • Microphone in the ear versus behind it. A 2024 study gave 10 people with mild to moderate loss two hearing aids that differed mainly in microphone position: one with its microphone in the ear canal, and a standard RIC. With directional processing and noise reduction switched off, the in-ear microphone gave significantly better localisation (66% versus 41% correct) and higher satisfaction. It also scored better for speech in noise, but that difference was not statistically significant (Kara et al., 2024).
  • Speech clarity. Other research has found little difference. Earlier work found similar speech understanding with in-the-ear and behind-the-ear hearing aids, and a 2023 study found people rated RIC and in-the-ear styles similarly for speech clarity (Kara et al., 2024, summarising Cox and Risberg, 1986, and Stone et al., 2023).

The trade-off

That 2024 study tested both hearing aids with their microphones in plain omnidirectional mode. In real life, the noise features matter, and this is where RICs often win back ground. Many smaller custom hearing aids have room for only one microphone, so they can’t use directional processing at all (Kara et al., 2024). RICs carry two or more, and modern premium models use them for advanced noise processing. Manufacturers also use “pinna restoration” processing to recreate some of the cues a behind-the-ear microphone misses.

RIC with custom mouldITE / ITCCIC / IIC
Microphone positionBehind and above the earAt the ear canal entranceInside the ear canal opening
Natural pinna cuesPartly recreated by processingLargely keptBest kept
Directional microphonesYes, two or moreOften, in larger modelsUsually not, single microphone
Seal and ventingExcellent seal; vent size limited by mouldGood seal; vent limited by shell spaceGood seal; least room for a vent
FeedbackLeast prone, as microphone and receiver are far apartModerateMost prone, as microphone and receiver are close
Best suited toMost people, especially those who struggle in noisePeople wanting a discreet, all-in-one device with room for featuresPeople prioritising discretion and natural sound with milder losses

Our view at AIM Hearing: for most people whose main problem is background noise, a RIC with a custom mould gives the best of both: a properly sealed fit plus the full set of directional and noise features. A custom ITE or ITC can be an excellent choice too, especially for people who prefer an all-in-one device and whose ears have room for a model with two microphones. We’ll talk through which suits your ears, your hearing and your priorities.

Why “most of the time”?

The research above is clear about the physics, and in our clinic it holds true for the overwhelming majority of the people we fit. When they move from domes to custom moulds, most tell us conversations in cafes, clubs and around the dinner table become noticeably easier to follow.

But every so often we meet someone who will swear on a stack of Bibles that they hear better in noise with domes. And who are we to tell them otherwise? Hearing is personal, and the person wearing the hearing aids is the final judge of what works.

There are some good reasons this can happen:

  • Their low-frequency hearing is close to normal. A dome lets natural sound in, and for some people their own ears are still doing a lot of the work in the low pitches.
  • Their own voice. If a sealed mould makes their voice sound boomy, that distraction can make a noisy room feel harder, even when the hearing aid is technically doing more.
  • What they’re used to. Someone who has worn domes for years has adapted to that sound. A change can take a few weeks to settle, and some people simply prefer the familiar.
  • The shape of their ears. Some ear canals hold a dome unusually snugly, and occasionally a mould needs adjusting before it fits as well as it should.
  • Real life isn’t a test booth. Research reports averages measured in a sound booth. Day-to-day listening also involves comfort, tiredness and confidence, and those differ from person to person.

So here’s how we handle it. We recommend based on the evidence and your own test results, and we verify every fitting with Real Ear Measurement. If you give custom moulds a fair trial and still prefer domes, we respect that. The best fitting is the one that works for you and that you’ll happily wear every day.

When domes are still the right choice

Domes are popular for good reasons. They can be fitted on the day, they’re comfortable, and they keep your own voice sounding natural. Research consistently shows people rate open fittings well for own-voice quality, comfort and appearance (Winkler et al., 2016).

The same review concluded that domes and large vents suit people with near-normal low-frequency hearing and a mild to moderate loss in the higher frequencies. For more significant losses, more closed fittings are recommended. Open fittings work best when your difficulty hearing in noise is mild (Kuk et al., 2005).

US audiologist Dr Cliff Olson makes a similar point in his video on domes versus earmoulds: some clinicians are dogmatic about earpieces, but every hearing loss needs a considered approach to get the best hearing and sound quality (Doctor Cliff, AuD, via The Hearing Wire). We agree. Custom moulds aren’t automatically right for everyone. They’re right for people whose priority is hearing in noise.

So a dome may be a sensible choice if:

  • your hearing loss is mild and mostly in the high pitches,
  • you mostly listen in quiet settings,
  • comfort or the most natural own-voice sound matters more to you than performance in noise, or
  • you want to start with domes while you get used to hearing aids, and move to moulds later.

What we recommend at AIM Hearing

If hearing better in background noise is your main reason for getting hearing aids, and especially if you’re investing in premium technology, we recommend custom moulds or custom receivers. Premium hearing aids earn their price mostly through how well they handle noise. A custom fit lets those features do their job instead of being bypassed by sound leaking around a dome.

Our approach is simple:

  1. We measure your hearing in noise, not just in quiet, at your hearing assessment.
  2. We talk through your priorities: noise, comfort, appearance, and how your own voice sounds.
  3. We take an impression of your ear if a custom fit suits you, and choose the material and vent size for your hearing.
  4. We verify the fit with Real Ear Measurement to confirm what’s actually reaching your eardrum.
  5. We fine-tune the vent at follow-up if your own voice needs it.

If you already wear hearing aids with domes and still struggle in noisy places, a custom mould may be a simple upgrade worth trying before you consider new hearing aids. Call us on 07 4153 1317 or book an appointment online.

Further reading

If you’d like to look into this yourself, these are the sources used in this article:

Scroll to Top
Call 07 4153 1317